Checklist: Security Questions to Ask Your CLM Vendor
A comprehensive security evaluation framework for enterprise contract management platforms. Use this checklist to ensure your CLM vendor meets enterprise security standards.
Contract data represents some of your organization's most sensitive information—pricing strategies, partnership terms, competitive advantages, and legal obligations. Before trusting a CLM vendor with this data, ensure they meet enterprise security standards with this comprehensive evaluation checklist.
Infrastructure & Data Security
✓ Essential Questions:
- Data Encryption: Is data encrypted both in transit (TLS 1.3+) and at rest (AES 256)?
- Key Management: How are encryption keys managed and rotated?
- Data Residency: Where is data stored geographically, and can you control this?
- Backup Security: Are backups encrypted with the same standards as production data?
- Infrastructure Security: What cloud provider do they use, and what security certifications do they maintain?
Access Control & Authentication
✓ Essential Questions:
- Single Sign-On (SSO): Do they support SAML 2.0 or OpenID Connect with your identity provider?
- Multi-Factor Authentication: Is MFA mandatory for admin accounts and configurable for all users?
- Role-Based Access Control: Can you define granular permissions and roles?
- Session Management: How are user sessions managed, timed out, and terminated?
- API Authentication: What authentication methods are supported for API access?
Compliance & Certifications
✓ Essential Questions:
- SOC 2 Type II: Do they have current SOC 2 Type II certification?
- GDPR Compliance: Are they GDPR compliant with data processing agreements available?
- Industry Standards: What other certifications do they maintain (ISO 27001, FedRAMP, HIPAA)?
- Data Processing Agreement: Do they provide comprehensive DPAs that meet your legal requirements?
- Right to Delete: Can data be completely deleted upon request (right to erasure)?
Audit Trail & Monitoring
✓ Essential Questions:
- Complete Audit Logs: Are all user actions, document changes, and system events logged?
- Log Integrity: Are audit logs tamper-proof and immutable?
- Log Retention: How long are audit logs retained, and can this be customized?
- Real-time Monitoring: Do they provide real-time security monitoring and alerting?
- Export Capabilities: Can audit logs be exported for your internal analysis?
Incident Response & Business Continuity
✓ Essential Questions:
- Incident Response Plan: Do they have a documented incident response plan?
- Breach Notification: What are their breach notification procedures and timelines?
- SLA Guarantees: What uptime guarantees do they provide (99.9%+)?
- Disaster Recovery: What is their RTO (Recovery Time Objective) and RPO (Recovery Point Objective)?
- Status Transparency: Do they provide a public status page with real-time system health?
Vendor Security Practices
✓ Essential Questions:
- Security Testing: Do they conduct regular penetration testing and vulnerability assessments?
- Employee Security: What security training and background checks do they require for employees?
- Code Security: Do they follow secure development practices (SAST, DAST, dependency scanning)?
- Third-Party Assessments: Do they undergo regular third-party security audits?
- Bug Bounty Program: Do they have a responsible disclosure/bug bounty program?
Integration & API Security
✓ Essential Questions:
- API Security: Are APIs secured with OAuth 2.0 or similar standards?
- Rate Limiting: Do they implement API rate limiting and DDoS protection?
- IP Whitelisting: Can API access be restricted to specific IP ranges?
- Integration Security: How do they secure integrations with third-party systems (CRM, e-signature)?
- Webhook Security: Are webhooks signed and verified for integrity?
Red Flags to Watch For
- Vague or evasive answers about security practices
- No SOC 2 certification or unwillingness to share compliance documentation
- Shared infrastructure without tenant isolation
- No encryption at rest or outdated encryption standards
- Limited or no audit trail capabilities
- No documented incident response procedures
- Resistance to providing detailed security documentation
Documentation to Request
Don't rely on verbal assurances. Request these documents as part of your evaluation:
- SOC 2 Type II report (may require NDA)
- Security and compliance certifications
- Data Processing Agreement (DPA) template
- Incident response procedures
- Business continuity and disaster recovery plans
- Penetration testing summaries
- Security architecture documentation
Making the Final Decision
Security shouldn't be the only factor in your CLM decision, but it should be a deal-breaker if not adequately addressed. A vendor that takes security seriously will:
- Provide detailed, specific answers to all security questions
- Offer comprehensive documentation and certifications
- Be transparent about their security practices and limitations
- Demonstrate ongoing investment in security improvements
- Provide references from similar enterprise customers
See AccordFlow's Security in Action
AccordFlow maintains SOC 2 Type II certification, enterprise-grade encryption, and comprehensive audit trails. Review our security practices and compliance documentation.
View Security DetailsSchedule Security Demo